2020 April 19      Tools


Introduction


Ever seen those cheap leather punches for sale online?  There must be a hundred different ones on there.

Today, we're going to find out why a cheap one may not be such a good deal.



Reader-Supported Site

Articles like this one are possible only with the support of readers like you, when you use the links on here to purchase your gear. 

It doesn't add anything to your cost, and it lets me keep adding helpful articles to this site.   Thanks for your help!




In This Article

The Basic Design

What's Good About It

What's Bad About It

Conclusion


The Basic Design


No matter if the price is $10, $20, or even $30, most of these have the same basic design.

It's a "double lever", which is supposed to make it easier to punch through thick leather.  And it does, at first, if your copy has sharp cutters on it.

You'll notice that the structural components-- handles, levers, etc.-- are made from stamped sheet metal.



What's Good About It


The actual cutters are sharp, if you get a good set.  At first, they will punch through leather easily. 



When new, they make much cleaner holes than an old, used one does.

It does have a couple of oval punches, which you may need for belts, bags, or purses.

The package includes a couple of replacement anvils and a sharpening tool;  it does seem like you get quite a lot for this low price.  And at first, the build quality seems fairly impressive.


Table of Contents




What's Bad About It


The online description said the smallest punch was 2.5 mm.  On my copy, the smallest one is more like 3.0 mm.  With leatherworking, the punch diameters are pretty important, so that's an issue. 

The tool is made of stamped sheet metal, as virtually all the cheap ones are.  Since they made it extra-large, I thought it might not be as much of a problem.

But then I noticed something...



This is after punching three or four holes.  It's happening because the whole thing is crooked.  Here's another view that shows what I mean.



If it were just the plastic handles, there wouldn't be metal galling.  That's a result of misaligned steel. 

When you squeeze the handles, some of that kinetic energy goes into making the whole thing flex.  This seems to get worse, the more you use it.  It's intrinsic to the way this is made.



Table of Contents




Conclusion


This leather punch looks nice, but it could start to bend out of alignment after a short time.  Then it won't work so well.

Many people who would buy this are looking for something they'll use once or twice a year.  Will it even last for that?  No idea;  this one started to have issues in less than one day.

If you want one you can actually use much, I would highly recommend a real professional-grade punch.  That one is also made in USA, as it should be.  The cutters are replaceable, and the frame won't buckle from ordinary use. 


         


If you found this article helpful, please help me keep this website on-line by purchasing any of your stuff through these links.  Thank you for helping to make this site what it is!




    


Contact me:

3 p o.t o . 1 2 0 s t u d i o.. c o m


This won't directly copy and paste.  Please manually type it into your mail program.
No spaces between letters.




Home Page


Site Map


What's New!



Disclaimer

Copyright 2020.  All rights reserved.










Back to Top of Page